In-Depth Analysis of Casting and Machining Technologies

1. Technical Definitions and Core Principles

1.1 Casting Technology
Definition: A process of producing 3D metal components by solidifying molten metal in a mold cavity with cores and inserts. It is suitable for manufacturing metal parts with complex geometries.
Core Process:
  • Melting Stage: Metal raw materials (e.g., iron, aluminum, copper) are heated to a liquid state in a furnace (temperatures: aluminum 660°C, steel 1500°C+).
  • Mold Filling: Liquid metal is poured into the mold cavity by gravity or pressure (e.g., sand molds, metal molds).
  • Solidification:
    • Nucleation: Small solid particles (nuclei) form as the molten metal cools below its melting point (cooling rate affects grain size; die casting can reach 10-100°C/s).
    • Crystal Growth: Nuclei grow into grains, with directional solidification techniques controlling grain orientation to enhance strength.
  • Post-Processing: Sand removal, deburring, heat treatment (e.g., aging), and surface treatment (e.g., electroplating).
Advantages:
  • Complex structure forming: Capable of producing parts with hollow sections and irregular contours (e.g., engine blocks).
  • High material utilization: Scrap can be recycled, reducing batch production costs (mold amortization can lower unit costs by 30-50%).
Limitations:
  • Larger tolerance: Sand casting tolerance is ±0.5mm, die casting ±0.1mm (lower than CNC machining’s ±0.0025mm).
  • Rough surface: Surface roughness (Ra) typically 1.6-12.5μm, requiring secondary processing.
1.2 Machining Technology
Definition: A process of achieving precise dimensions and surface accuracy by removing material from workpieces using cutting tools, primarily controlled by CNC (Computer Numerical Control).
Core Process:

 

  • Programming: Generating G-code from CAD models to control tool paths (e.g., milling feed rates 100-3000mm/min).
  • Cutting:
    • Milling: Rotating tools machine planes and grooves (5-axis milling for complex surfaces like turbine blades).
    • Turning: Workpieces rotate while tools feed to produce axisymmetric parts (e.g., shafts, precision up to IT6 grade).
    • Grinding: Grinding wheels finish surfaces to achieve Ra 0.3μm.
  • Inspection: Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMM) check dimensional accuracy (precision ±0.001mm).

 

Advantages:

 

  • High precision: CNC machining tolerances as low as ±0.0025mm, suitable for medical implants (e.g., artificial joints) and aerospace components.
  • Diverse material compatibility: Processes metals (e.g., titanium alloys) and non-metals (e.g., PEEK, ceramics).

 

Limitations:

 

  • Material waste: Cutting removal rates can reach 30-70% (e.g., aerospace monolithic structures).
  • Challenging internal features: Deep cavities and intersecting holes require multi-step operations, reducing efficiency.

2. Process Types and Technical Parameter Comparisons

2.1 Casting Processes
Process Type Mold Material Typical Tolerance Production Volume Suitable Materials Applications
Sand Casting Quartz sand/resin sand ±0.5mm Small to large batches Cast iron, steel Engine blocks, machine bases
Die Casting H13 tool steel ±0.1mm Large batches Aluminum, zinc alloys Car wheels, electronic radiators
Investment Casting Wax mold + refractory coating ±0.3mm Small to medium batches High-temperature alloys, stainless steel Aerospace turbine blades
2.2 Machining Processes
Process Type Tool/Equipment Typical Tolerance Surface Roughness Ra Material Removal Rate Applications
5-Axis Milling Carbide end mills ±0.005mm 0.8-3.2μm 20%-50% Complex curved parts (e.g., impellers)
Turning Ceramic turning tools ±0.01mm 1.6-6.3μm 10%-30% Shafts (e.g., crankshafts)
EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining) Copper electrodes ±0.003mm 0.4-1.6μm Low (non-contact) Precision holes in hard materials (e.g., tungsten steel molds)
2.3 Key Technical Parameter Comparison
Dimension Casting Machining
Design Freedom Suitable for complex internal/hollow structures Suitable for sharp edges, fine surface textures
Production Efficiency High for mass production (reusable molds) Fast for prototyping/small batches (no mold needed)
Material Strength Directional solidification achieves near-raw material strength Retains dense structure, higher strength
Environmental Impact Generates metal fumes, CO emissions Cutting fluid pollution, metal scrap

3. Industry Applications and Selection Guidelines

3.1 Industry Application Comparison
Industry Casting Advantages Machining Advantages
Automotive Engine blocks, gearboxes (die casting) Precision gears (CNC milling)
Aerospace Titanium alloy structures (investment casting) Aerospace bolts (5-axis turning)
Medical Devices Prosthesis blanks (lost-wax casting) Joint surface finishing (grinding)
Electronics Aluminum alloy casings (low-pressure casting) Micro connectors (precision milling)

4. Technological Development Trends

  1. Casting Technology:
    • Digital Transformation: Simulation software (e.g., Moldflow) optimizes filling processes to reduce porosity.
    • Green Processes: Sandless 3D-printed molds (e.g., binder jetting) minimize environmental impact.
  2. Machining Technology:
    • Intelligentization: AI-adaptive cutting systems (e.g., FANUC i-Ai contour control) optimize parameters in real time.
    • Hybrid Machining: Turn-mill composite machines (e.g., MAZAK INTEGREX) enable multi-process machining in one setup.
  3. Process Integration:
    • Near-Net Shape + Precision Machining: Casting for rough shapes followed by CNC for precision, reducing material waste by 30%.

5. Conclusion

Choosing between casting and machining depends on design requirements, strength, precision, and production scale. Machining is ideal for high-precision, low-to-medium volume, and diverse material needs. Casting suits complex geometries, large sizes, and mass production.
Modern manufacturing increasingly integrates both technologies—casting for basic shapes and CNC for finishing—to achieve high-quality, cost-effective results.
RapidDirect, a leading provider of CNC machining and metal casting, offers multi-axis CNC and die casting services globally, along with custom mold fabrication. For prototyping, vacuum casting provides cost-effective solutions without high mold costs.

Common Questions

  • Are screws cast or machined?
    While castable, screws are better machined for precise thread strength. CNC threading tools handle various sizes, even small screws via Swiss machining.
  • Which is stronger: cast or machined aluminum?
    Machined aluminum retains raw material properties, while cast aluminum’s strength depends on grain structure.
  • How to choose between die casting and CNC machining?
    Die casting for mass production of complex shapes; CNC machining for small batches with tight tolerances.

Recommended Reading